Search News


Browse Archives

News

2-Year Honors Boom

February 4, 2010

Share This Story

FREE Daily News Alerts

Advertisement

Amid the enrollment boom at community colleges, two-year honors programs have become more popular and – in some cases – more competitive than ever among traditional-age students.

Highline Community College, in Washington State, piloted its program in 2003 with 15 students. It grew to 100 students in 2005. This semester, it has more than 250 students. Barbara Clinton, director of Highline's honors program, said that 95 percent of students who complete at least 15 hours of honors credit go on to graduate from a four-year institution. Cape Cod Community College, in Massachusetts, started an honors program for the first time last semester and has 88 students enrolled, with plans to grow.

Last year, the National Collegiate Honors Council – a professional association of undergraduate honors programs and colleges – had 167 community college members, representing more than 13 percent of its membership. Though this was the first year the association began asking its members to self-identify as either two- or four-year institutions, there is no question among its officials that the number of community college programs has grown and will continue to do so.

"Although every honors program is different, a typical honors program consists of a sequence of seminar courses that either supplements or substitutes for a student’s general education or distribution requirements," reads the council's definition of these programs. "Many honors programs and colleges include a capstone project or thesis. Honors programs are available for students in most majors, and rarely require students to take more courses or credits than non-honors students. Students who complete an honors program or college typically receive honors designation on their transcripts and/or diplomas."

Phi Theta Kappa, an honor society for community college students, has chapters at 1,250 two-year institutions around the world. However, induction into the honor society is not predicated on participation in an honors program with its own separate and advanced coursework; 43.5 percent of its chapters reported that their institution had an honors program last year.

Rod Risley, executive director of Phi Theta Kappa, noted that he has witnessed the spread of honors programs to more of the society’s chapters.

“What we’ve typically seen during recessionary periods is more non-traditional-age students enrolling in community colleges,” Risley said. “These past two years have been very important, though, because what we’ve seen is more full-time, traditional-age students enrolling. What this is reflecting is not just an increase in the number of high school graduates but that more and more of these traditional-age students are electing to go to community colleges first. They see these honors programs as attractive recruitment tools, but also as a track to a selective or highly selective institution.… There’s an interesting dynamic among millennial students; they’re prone to stay closer to home. Why not stay home, pay less for the first two years of college and get access to these selective or highly selective institutions?”

Attracting University-Bound Students

The 36-year-old honors program at Lee College, located 22 miles east of Houston, saw record enrollment in its four honors courses last fall. John Britt, honors program coordinator and history professor, said he received about 100 applicants for the 70 slots in the program, and said that he expects the process to become more competitive in future semesters. In recent years, he said, the program has attracted more students who have turned down admission to nearby four-year institutions for financial reasons.

“More and more of our students in the program are coming here because they can’t afford to go off elsewhere,” Britt said. “Right now, I have students who were admitted to the University of Texas [at Austin] and Baylor [University] who couldn’t do it right now because they didn’t have enough money, even with scholarships.… These students also realize that, when they get ready to transfer, this program will help them with its articulation agreements.”

The Art & Phyllis Grindle Honors Institute at Seminole State College of Florida has seen its enrollment more than double in the past five years. In 2005, the program enrolled 73 students; last fall, it enrolled 168 students.

Laura Ross, director of the honors program, said the college has been able to expand the capacity of the program and further market it thanks to a $1 million donation it received from a local businessman in 2006.

“Some of the growth might be the economy,” Ross said. “Also, it might be that some students weren’t aware of the program before. We've done a good job of making more of them aware of it before and when they get here.”

The honors program at Seminole State limits its class sizes to 22 – at least five students fewer than the average at the college – and gives some merit aid to all its students, based on the number of honors courses they take. “Right now, we’re fine and taking care of all of our students,” Ross said. “We may reach a point where we’re not able to give out as much scholarship money if we have more and more students in our program. We haven’t put a limit on it at this point. But, if we get to 250 students, I would be concerned that we wouldn't be able to serve all of our students.”

Seattle Central Community College is among the many two-year institutions planning to add an honors college. Nada Oakley, the college’s Phi Theta Kappa adviser and an English professor, said the college's hope is to start the program in the winter term of 2011. She said that Seattle Central’s large population of transfer students, many of whom expressed to the college a desire for an honors program, should make this a popular option.

The program will start small, Oakley added, with 25 students in its first term. She expects that about 50 to 60 students will apply for these spots. The future expansion of the program, she said, depends on institutional finances.

“I’d like to call our honors program a populist movement,” Oakley said. “We did some research and this is what we came up with. Students wanted a program that was a combination of honors courses, leadership building activities as well as some sort of research project. We’ve also had the buy-in of a lot of faculty, too. … I imagine this’ll turn into a destination for local high school students as well as local adults looking to start over for whatever reason.”

See all postings »
Advertisement
Advertisement

Matching Jobs

Comments on 2-Year Honors Boom

  • Dispels Stereotypes
  • Posted by David , English at Jefferson Community and Technical College on February 4, 2010 at 9:15am EST
  • Members of the public often think of community colleges as schools of last resort, the limbo of higher education; however, community colleges often attract bright, highly motivated students who simply could not afford the more expensive tuition at a four-year institution or non-traditional students who have been out of high school for a number of years. Our college has several honors programs as well as both Psi Beta and Phi Theta Kappa. One of the teachers in an honors program is one of our former students who now has a Ph.D. As tuition rises into the stratosphere, more and more intellectually gifted students will start their post-secondary education at a community college.

  • Honors for all?
  • Posted by Prof. Ira Shor , Professor, PHD Program in English at CUNY Graduate Center, College of Staten Island on February 4, 2010 at 10:30am EST
  • Why not make the whole community college curriculum an Honors program? Why should only a select few benefit from the same things that all students need? Smaller classes? Full-time faculty? Extra attention from the institution? Project-based learning? Sounds like things all cc students need. Providing higher quality conditions to an elite handful of students and faculty will further degrade the status of non-Honors teachers and students. Democracy means a level-playing field and equal protection for all, not tracking and privileging.

  • Exactly
  • Posted by Brian Reed , Doctoral Candidate at UVA on February 4, 2010 at 12:45pm EST
  • Ira,

    My exact question. Schooling and the social order...

  • Honors programs and contingent faculty
  • Posted by Howard Tinberg , Professor of English at Bristol Community College on February 4, 2010 at 1:00pm EST
  • I wonder how long this Honor's boom will continue when full-time instructors are phased out at community colleges, a process that is clearly underway? Will contingent faculty have the means and opportunities and rewards to mentor students, as honors programs require? I think not.

  • Democracy does not mean equal ability
  • Posted by David , English at Jefferson Community and Technical College on February 4, 2010 at 2:45pm EST
  • A democratic society should have equality of opportunity, but this does not mean that everyone is equal. Honor students earn their status with high standardized test scores, good grades, and motivation. No one suggests that every one is equal in sports. No one asks why can't everyone play in the NBA, so why should we think that everyone is equal in intellectual ability? Many neither students have the desire to be in honors programs nor do they have the higher order intellectual abilities of critical thinking to be in such a program. Even at Harvard not every student is equal in ability or talent.

  • Honors equality
  • Posted by Dr. F. Gump on February 4, 2010 at 6:00pm EST
  • Brian and Ira, David is exactly right. Our institution offers honors credit in many subject areas, however, when students are introduced to the amount of additional writing or other academic work required to earn the "honors" code on their transcripts, most drop the course. Students in the U.S.A. are, by and large, averse to earning an education; they just want a diploma or certificate.

    Foreign students, for the most part, get a good laugh at the laziness of U.S. students; the latter don't like to work all the math problem sets or write more than a few paragraphs in their native language. Our students have been fed far too many carrots (and burgers) and had all too few challenges (sticks).

  • Posted by chaosakita on February 4, 2010 at 10:15pm EST
  • What exactly is the point of this? Does anyone actually care that you have an "Honors" Associates Degree? With so many unemployed college graduates, who thinks that their special degree is any more appealing? If talented students really have to resort to community colleges because of atmospheric tuition fees, that's an overall problem with the college system.

  • Community College Honors programs
  • Posted by Kathleen Schatzberg , President at Cape Cod Community College on February 5, 2010 at 10:00am EST
  • A couple comments, one to set the record straight:

    The Cape Cod Community College Honors program has actually been operating quite successfully for 6 or 7 years. The state's Dept. of Higher Education initiated an accreditation process, internal to public higher education in Massachusetts, that provides seamless transition from community college honors programs to the University of Massachusetts Honors College, and that process was completed a year ago, but the program itself has been vibrant for many years.

    Second -- I agree with Ira Shor and others that the pedagogical features of most honors programs would benefit all students. Yet community colleges, while serving the neediest of students, are funded far less per student than public 4-year institutions, so quite simply, we can't provide these kinds of enrichments and enhancements to all students. I agree there is an ethical dilemma in the question of whether we provide a limited services to, say 5% of the most talented students, or, in spreading those resources among 100% of students, provide so little that it has no impact. It's time for the public, policy makers, and government officials to recognize the value to society and the economy that comes from providing as many resources to all community college students as we do to those who enter public 4-year institutions.

    Finally -- to Chaosakita -- your prejudice is showing.

    Kathleen Schatzberg, President, Cape Cod Community College

  • lazy American Students
  • Posted by Brian , Assistant Director of Inst Res at Eastern Connecticut State Univ on February 5, 2010 at 11:00am EST
  • Dr. Gump,

    I ask this not as a challenge to what you are saying (in fact I believe it), but because I want to gather empirical evidence to do something about the problem. You mention how slack American students are compared to international students when it comes to things like challenging math problems. Do you know of any documents, whether based on rigorous research or just anecdotal stuff, that would support your claim?

    I'm interested in possibly developing my institution's relationships with community colleges to enhance education for transfer students.

    Thanks!

  • Resources for Student Achievers
  • Posted by Anne McGrail , English Instructor, Learning Communities Coordinator at Lane Community College on February 5, 2010 at 2:00pm EST
  • I just wanted to say for the record that at our institution, developmental classes (for underprepared students) have class sizes that are between 20 and 50% smaller than college-level courses, and many of them are taught by full-time faculty. So while I agree with Dr. Schor in principle, I think that putting some small portion of our resources to support poor but talented students' continued high achievement would contribute to a larger project of social justice.